Superconducting cable systems

SuperNode was born from the realisation that the grid as currently constituted will not be capable of handling the increased share of renewable energy necessary to achieve decarbonisation. The combination of significantly increasing our renewable energy share and electrifying our economies is essential to decarbonisation. However, if we continue adding renewable energy at our current pace, many of our grids will be overwhelmed by 2030. Conventional cable technology is capacity constrained and will not be capable of transmitting the required levels of renewable power needed in the system. This will delay the construction of new renewable infrastructure, costing time and money that we cannot afford.

We need more innovative cables, capable of transferring large amounts of power over long distances efficiently. SuperNode is developing these cables using superconductor technology. Superconductors are a phenomenon in some materials that when cooled to very low temperatures can transmit power with zero electrical losses. These cables can carry huge amounts of power in a much smaller surface area than conventional cables and require significantly less infrastructure, materials and space. 

SuperNode’s superconductors will be the perfect technology to enable the electricity age.

Superconducting Cable Systems for bulk power transfer.

Conventional cables are limited in terms of current levels which in turn limit their power transfer capability. For this reason, ultra-high voltage schemes (above 500kV) are being developed. This conventional tech trend for higher voltages delivers projects and installations with very large, obtrusive footprints.

Superconducting cable systems can alleviate this issue while integrating with existing direct current and alternating current electrical technologies.

To date, superconducting cable system power applications have been restricted to lower distribution levels to increase power transfer capabilities in urban settings where the greater power densities provided and smaller footprints of superconducting cable systems are ideal given that space is at a premium. Examples of these include the AmpaCity project in Essen, Germany and the Shingal Project in Seoul, South Korea.

SuperNode is focusing on developing more efficient superconducting cable systems to enable higher level, bulk power transfer and novel implementation scenarios.

A superconductor is a material that can conduct electricity with no resistance.

However in order for the material to be superconductive it must be at a temperature at or below its “critical temperature”.

Unfortunately for most materials the critical temperature is very low – for materials classed as High Temperature Superconductors (HTS) this is around -200°C, while for materials classed as Low Temperature Superconductors this is below -243°C. Therefore in order for superconductors to be useful, cooling that can bring down the superconductor to below its critical temperature is required.

This temperature requirement means that use of superconductors has been limited, but they can be seen in applications such as superconducting magnets, ranging in use cases from MRI machines to the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at CERN.

SuperNode cable demonstrating superconductivity

Given the very low temperatures that are required by superconductors, additional hardware is required in superconducting cables in order to keep the superconductor in the required temperature range. This is usually achieved by submerging the superconductor in a very low temperature cryogenic fluid, such as helium or liquid nitrogen.

Two challenges arise from this:

1) How do we contain the cryogenic fluid around the superconducting cables while preventing the fluid from heating up too much?

2) When the fluid heats up how do we cool it back down?

The first challenge is typically addressed by placing the superconducting cable in a cryostat, which is a multi-layered pipe that provides sufficient thermal insulation to drastically reduce the rate at which the cryogenic fluid heats up. At least one of the layers is typically a high performance thermal insulator such as an aerogel or a vacuum.

The second challenge can be addressed by replacing the fluid (i.e. using a constant cryogen supply), or by re-cooling the cryogen using advanced refrigeration devices called cryocoolers.

Novel Cryostat Materials

SuperNode is developing novel material solutions to meet the most exacting marine and terrestrial requirements.

The key to SuperNode’s technology is efficiently extending the distance between the re-cooling of the liquid nitrogen (LN2). Current state-of-the-art superconducting cables deploy a corrugated steel cryostat to house the flow of LN2, which is designed to allow for the expansion and contraction of the materials across the 200°C temperature range. While this design addresses the challenge of thermal expansion, it significantly increases the friction, turbulence and pressure drop within the cryostat, thereby reducing the distance the LN2 can flow without requiring re-cooling.

Superconducting cable with smooth bore inner cryostat

SuperNode is developing a smooth-bore inner cryostat. This enables vastly reduced friction, turbulence and pressure loss compared to current state-of-the-art. In order to accomplish this, the cryostat materials must have an extremely low co-efficient of thermal expansion. SuperNode is developing novel materials using bespoke equipment with cryogenic capabilities, such as the Dilatometer and the Instron cryogenic tensile tester.

Example of SuperNode outer cryostat
Instron Cryogenic Tensile Tester 

Optimal Thermal Management: Insultation

SuperNode is developing world class insulation which prevents heat leakage into the inner cryostat. This work further extends the distance between re-cooling. SuperNode’s insulation efforts have broken NASA’s record for soft vacuum insulation (1Pa – 10Pa).

SuperNode operates a custom-built Vertical Insulation Test Rig (VITR) to simulate real world conditions and to test insulations under a range of vacuums at cryogenic temperatures. The VITR measures the amount of thermal energy that passes through the insulation, providing valuable data on performance and efficiency.

SuperNode also collaborates closely with academics and industry to further develop optimised solutions for insulation.

Vertical Insulated Test Rig
 

Optimal Thermal Management: Vacuum

The deployment of a vacuum reinforces the insulation and minimises thermal losses of the inner cryostat. SuperNode is working with world leaders in cryogenics to develop a best-in-class vacuum to further increase cryogenic and thermal efficiency of the system, ultimately reducing cost and increasing transmission distances.

The most notable partnership is with CERN, the European Laboratory for Particle Physics. CERN is a world leader in cryogenics and vacuum systems. SuperNode have deployed an employee to CERN where initial materials testing is ongoing. CERN will also design a test rig for SuperNode which will ultimately be installed in SuperNode’s Dublin Headquarters, the European Cryogenics Centre for Superconductors (ECCS)

Scale Manufacturing

SuperNode are not just focused on designing a prototype and proving the technology but also in developing a process to manufacture the cables at scale.

SuperNode operates out of its Dublin Based headquarters, the European Cryogenic Centre for Superconductors. This is a purpose built 1,400m² state-of-the-art facility designed for the production of prototypes and demonstration projects.

European Cryogenic Centre for Superconductors

We are collaborating with key industrial partners to develop continuous manufacturing processes. By 2026 we plan to have a fully capable Alpha Facility and a high capacity Beta Facility by 2030 to serve our addressable market. 

Offshore Applications

Networks based upon superconducting cable systems can move larger quantities of power over longer distances with smaller and less obtrusive infrastructure and without electrical losses. The reduction in footprint for infrastructure is particularly evident for offshore applications in comparison to competing technologies. Superconducting cable system connecting offshore wind farm

Onshore Applications

Superconductivity enables extremely high densities of power to move through a relatively small surface area compared to conventional cables. In the onshore setting, this allows for an optimisation of rights-of-way and transmission corridors. Superconducting cables can carry huge amounts of power, up to 10GW in a single cable. This enables unobstrusive bulk power transfer. Overhead lines have traditionally been the most efficient and cost-effective way to move power. However, overhead lines have become increasingly difficult to build due to public opposition. 
 
The below image outlines a visual comparison of a superconducting cable corridor alongside an overhead line and conventional copper cable corridor of equivalent power transmission.
Space constraints will become an ever bigger challenge as the energy transition develops and superconducting cables will offer the most efficient transmission corridors for bulk power.
Shingal, South Korea, 2019

Description: The Shingal Project is a 1 km 23 kV AC HTS cable connecting the 154 kV substations of Shingal and Heungdeok.

Design: 23 kV, 1.6 kA triad configured HTS cable with 50 km of HTS tape used. The cable will act to share the supply capacity between the Shingal sub-station and the underutilised Heungdeok substation.

Results: The system operated as planned and, during commissioning, all tests proved successful. This has led KEPCO to investigate the further applica-tion of the 23 kV system as well as AC 154 kV HTS cables in succession to the Shingal Project success. [16]

Ishikari, Japan, 2015

Description: National project in which a 500-m cable connected an Internet data centre (iDC) to a large scale array of photovoltaic cells to supply DC power.

Design: Construction of two DC superconducting power cables of 500 m (Line 1) and 1,000 m length (Line 2) respectively. The cable of the Line 1 is installed into the underground and composed of two cables.

Results: The heat leak of the cryogenic pipe is ~1.4 W / m, including the cable pipe and the return pipe. The heat leak of the current lead is ~30 W / kA in the test bench. Finally, a current of 6 kA / 3sec and a current of 5 kA / 15 min were achieved in Line 1.

Saint Petersburg, Russia, 2016

Description: Cables between two substations in downtown St. Petersburg spanning a distance of 2.5 km. Connecting the 330 kV ‘Tserntralnaya’ and 220 kV ‘RP-9’ substations will provide reserve power network capacity, allowing new consumers to connect to the system and improve system reliability and limit fault currents for existing end users.

Design: 50 MW, 20 kV HTS DC cable on 2.5 km.

Results: Tests were conducted on two 30-meter cable samples, two 430-meter cables, three pairs of current leads and three joints. Critical current (IC) tests were carried out at 68 K to 78 K; resistance remained stable and the cable performed as expected. The cables also passed high-voltage testing.

Germany, Hungary, Norway, Belgium, Sweden, Spain, Denmark, Switzerland, France, United Kingdom and Italy 2017

Description: BEST PATHS was a collaborative project of 40 leading European organisations from science and industry, supported by the EC FP7 (2014 – 2018). The project investigated the feasibility of technological innovations that could advance high-capacity transmission links. This included a demonstrator project dedicated to superconducting electric lines, to validate the novel MgB2 technology for GW-level HVDC power transmission.

Design: Through insulated cross-arms, long-term tests with HTLS as well as dynamic line rating, existing lines are to be optimised to maximise power transmission.

Results: The operation of a full-scale 320 kV MgB2 monopole cable system that can transfer up to 3.2 GW was demonstrated (demonstration nb. 5 of the project).

Essen, Germany, 2014

Description: The AmpaCity project is a 1 km 10 kV HTS cable installed in 2014 to replace a 110 kV underground cable system connecting two 10 kV substations in Essen Germany.

Design: The three-phase, concentric cable replaces the conventional 110 kV copper line connecting two substations in central Essen and eliminates the need for a high-voltage transformer at one of the substations.

Results: The cost of the energy required to cool the cable down to eliminate its resistance over its lifecycle was found to be 15% lower than the equivalent cost of compensating losses in conventional 110 kV cables. HTS are mentioned as the best technical and economically viable solution to avoid the necessary extension of the 110 kV grid in urban areas.

Oak Ridge National Laboratory (Phase 1), Yonkers, NY (Phase 2), USA, 2016

Description: The HYDRA project Phase 1 was a 25 m prototype that was successfully tested at Oak Ridge National Laboratory. Phase 2 consists in connecting two substations in Westchester County. This HTS FCL Cable installation will allow the asset sharing of a 13.8 kV transformer combined with fault current protection to equipment.

Design: Phase 1 using 25 m HTS FCL Cable, phase 2 aims at connecting 2 Con Edison 13.8 kV substations with a cable length of 170 m.

Results: Phase 1 of the projects helped the qualification of HTS FCL cable for Power Network.

DNV Statement of Feasibility (PDF)

High Temperature Superconductor Cables: ENTSO-E Technopedia – https://www.entsoe.eu/Technopedia/techsheets/high-temperature-superconductor-hts-cables

SuperNode Superconductor Cable shown by University of Strathclyde & ORE Catapult to be Competitive with HVDC – 
https://supernode.energy/uncategorised/supernode-superconductor-cable-shown-by-university-of-strathclyde-ore-catapult-to-be-competitive-with-hvdc/

In Best Paths, gigawatt-scale superconducting cables were investigated and shown to be technologically mature and cost-competitive for the transmission of large amounts of electricity. Thanks to their high efficiency, compact size, and reduced environmental impact, superconducting cables are likely to find higher public acceptance than overhead lines and conventional cables” – Marian, A. Bruzek, C.E. (2018) ‘ Advancing superconducting links for very high power transmission. IASS Brochure. http://www.bestpaths-project.eu/contents/publications/white-paper-best-paths-iass-online.pdf

Regarding HVDC cables, recurring to superconductivity technologies and namely High Temperature Cables (HTC) may be technically and economically convenient when the increase of transmission capacity need over a corridor requests the addition of more cables in parallel….Therefore, it would be beneficial to develop HTC technologies for Superconducting Transmission Lines (STL) to explore its potential in situations where very high amounts of power need to be transmitted. Studies have proposed the very high continuous power capacity HTS DC cable system in the range of 5 to 20 GW at 200 kV.” – ‘Clean Energy Transition – Technologies and Innovations’, European Commission, p 199-200, 213-215.
See document attached (PDF)

The Superconducting Transmission Lines (SCTL) main advantages are higher transmission efficiency and ability to use lower operating voltages while still preserving the total capacity. Potential applications for transport of high amounts of energy or in EU congested grid context is then key for the development of the grid and to increase its efficiency.” – Horizon Europe – Work Programme 2021-2022, Climate, Energy and Mobility. https://sciencebusiness.net/sites/default/files/inline-files/11-2-WP-Climate-Energy-Mobility-February-2021.pdf

Key industry-informed questions

SuperNode’s superconducting cable system is specifically designed to be compatible with conventional equipment and techniques for deployment and operation. In the marine (offshore) context this includes compatibility with conventional vessels, cable handling and deployment techniques and equipment, trenching equipment, subsea rated power and control systems, and the competencies associated with the deployment and operation of this equipment. Of particular note is SuperNode’s development of novel joints for individual cable section ends, which enables the joining of multiple sections during deployment through a simple and rapid ‘plug’ operation, avoiding the need to splice superconducting cables in the field. In the onshore context the cable is designed for transport on road reels and deployment and management with conventional equipment.

Just one-third of the materials utilised in superconducting cables consist of metals obtained through primary mining activities or as mining by-products. However, these metals can all be obtained from secondary (recycled) sources. Copper is a critical metal to the energy transition and to power grids, and has seen demand and prices skyrocket. Superconducting cables require 85% less copper than conventional cables for equivalent power transmission which would shield SuperNode from copper markets. Other critical metals like Silver, Nickel and Rare earths are required in tiny quantities.

All of the other materials used in superconducting cables are non-metals and can be manufactured and therefore have a minimum supply risk. 100% of materials used in superconducting cables are recyclable when they reach their end-of-life.
Lead, which is used for corrosion resistance in conventional cables, is identified by the EU as a substance of very high concern and has been recommended to be included in Annex XIV of the REACH (Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals). There is No lead (Pb) found within a Superconducting Cable. None of the materials used in superconducting cables are listed on the REACH authorisation list.

LN2 which is used to cool the superconducting tape, can be extracted out of air, which is approximately 78% Nitrogen.

The installation of SuperNode’s superconducting cable is performed similar to standard power cables, with cables transported to location on standard cable drums/reels. The cables are then placed in ducts or buried directly in the ground depending on the location and application.

Superconducting cables typically require an active control system for cooling and recirculation of liquid nitrogen. These systems are autonomous in operation and require very little maintenance throughout the operational life of the system.
Qualification of AC superconducting cables is performed in accordance with IEC 63075 ‘’ Superconducting ac power cables and their accessories for rated voltages from 6 kV to 500 kV – Test methods and requirements ‘’ and Cigre TB 538 ‘’ Recommendations for testing of superconducting cables ‘’ and Cigre TB 644 ‘’Common Characteristics and Emerging Test Techniques for High Temperature Superconducting Power Equipment ‘’.

For DC Superconducting cables there is currently no qualification standards, a combination of standards will be required, leveraging on the experience of AC superconductors and also extruded cable qualification such as IEC 62067 “Power cables with extruded insulation and their accessories for rated voltages above 150 kV (Um = 170 kV) up to 500 kV (Um = 550 kV) – Test methods and requirements’’, IEC 62895 ‘’ High voltage direct current (HVDC) power transmission – Cables with extruded insulation and their accessories for rated voltages up to 320 kV for land applications – Test methods and requirements’’ & Cigre TB852 ‘’ Recommendations for testing DC extruded cable systems for power transmission at a rated voltage up to and including 800 kV ’’ and Cigre TB

Both AC and DC Superconducting cables have advantages and disadvantages depending on the application.

For high-capacity power transmission, DC cables can be utilised over longer distances than AC cables. DC cables do not experience the same electrical losses as AC making them more efficient in power transmission. Most national grids however, operate with an AC system therefore DC transmission requires large infrastructure (Converter Stations) for the technology to be integrated with existing networks.

SuperNode are developing both AC and DC superconducting cables for a variety of different applications, AC superconducting cables for small scale power applications such as grid resilience in urban dense locations and DC superconducting cables for large-scale point to point power transmission, and meshed DC rids.

SuperNode’s cable is approximately the same physical size as conventional cables today. A key advantage of SuperNode’s superconducting cable design is its scalability. The superconducting cable can be designed to deliver significantly higher powers without any geometry change. This means that for a given geometry the cable power can be significantly increased without requiring bigger cables or increasing the number of cables for a given power transfer requirement. For example, today’s conventional state-of-the-art technology is 525kV DC cables, with the ability to typically transfer 2GW of power in a bi-pole configuration. For additional power transfer requirements (i.e. >2.0GW) the projects will require an additional pair(s) of cables. SuperNode’s superconducting cables however, can be scaled from 1 – 10GW in the same cryostat geometry.

Vacuum degradation and the associated impact on thermal insulation performance is one of the most significant challenges that SuperNode are working on. To this end we have developed bespoke test equipment for measuring insulation performance, and we are working with different collaborators within this space. The most prominent of these projects has been undertaken with CERN to understand how the novel materials SuperNode are developing interact with the vacuum over the lifetime of the cryostat. The mechanical loading on the system during its deployment and lifetime are well understood, and are a key input to the design specifications for the system.

In terms of integrating SuperNode’s High Temperature Superconductor (HTS) technology with standard power conversion and switchgear architectures and equipment, several considerations need to be addressed:

  • Power Converters: To integrate HTS devices with standard power systems, power converters are used to convert the alternating current (AC) from the grid to the appropriate direct current (DC) for the HTS equipment. Conversely, when power is fed back to the grid from HTS devices, power converters are required to convert DC back to AC.
  • Protection and switchgear: HTS devices need proper protection against faults and overcurrent events. Specialised switchgear that can handle high current levels and interrupt fault currents can be designed and implemented. The cables themselves can be designed as fault tolerant and inherently react with increased impedance to grid faults, firewalling and/or protecting against propagation of faults in meshed grids.
  • Grid compatibility: The integration of HTS technology with existing power systems requires compatibility with the grid’s voltage levels, frequency, and control systems. This can seamlessly be accommodated as per codes and requirements.
  • Scalability: HTS cable technology is ideally suited for large power applications. Multiples of power capacity can be achieved with minimal increases in cable geometry and cost, unlike conventional cables which scale proportionally in cost and size for power capacity increases.

 SuperNode, with its partners in industry and academia, is actively supporting the development of integration and protection technologies that can optimally leverage the power characteristics of its HTS cable such that compelling system-wide value proposition can be realised across high-capacity, renewables-based transmission networks.  

Firstly, it’s important to consider the similarities between a superconductor cable system (SCS) and conventional technologies. For both, the end effects of major structural damage is the same i.e. loss of electrical transmission.

Like conventional technologies, our system is designed for use in the given operational environment so the main cause of this damage would either be defects of the system during production, deployment loads beyond the specified limits or rare accidental events (including anchor strikes, digger strikes and trawler impact).

The key differences lie in what physically happens to the cable and how we address these issues. Given the design architecture of the SCS, catastrophic damage can affect several different parts, but the main system-level effect for the SCS is damage to the thermal performance, which in turn can cause sections of the system to heat up and lose superconductivity. Dependent on the extent of the damage, the SCS could continue functioning at reduced capacity until repairs are needed.

For conventional cables, most cases of damage are addressed by finding and repairing the affected section of the cable, which itself is an onerous task. A key benefit of the SCS is the embedded detection systems and its modularity. A digital twin initiative will be implemented which actively monitors the cable’s operational condition and feeds the date to predictive models that trigger control protection and maintenance actions. In the event of failure, location of any damage to the system can be established down to the one-meter section of cable where it occurred which facilitates local intervention or expedited replacement of a specific damaged cable module.

Generally these risks are low, but they are reduced even further by controlling the manufacturing processes, embedding safety within the design, and qualifying the cable beyond the basic operational conditions to ensure it remains robust throughout its operational life.

Firstly, the fault parameters are clearly defined, namely fault current and fault duration. These are determined by examining the HTS cable circuit and the operational and emergency scenarios to which it will be exposed. The maximum current the cable will experience during a fault and the fault duration are determined and form a design input to the HTS cable. A shunt made of copper is added to the cable assembly and is sized accordingly to the fault current and fault duration. During a fault, the copper shunt and high temperature superconducting (HTS) material share the fault current. The copper shunt protects the cable from damage as it has been designed to handle the fault current for the fault duration. Current limiters or a trip switch can also be used used to cut power to the cable and protect the cable such that design fault current or duration is not exceeded. SuperNode has conducted various simulations and laboratory test programs to ensure our cables can withstand any fault conditions they might encounter during their service life.

SuperNode’s superconducting cable is being put through a comprehensive qualification and demonstration program under the review of a third-party certification body. This program will subject the cable to a wide suite of tests (both industry standard and novel) which will verify the reliability and safety of SuperNode’s cable and all required ancillaries through the entire lifecycle of the system. In addition, while current generation superconductors do require active cooling, SuperNode are designing the active elements of the system with appropriate redundancy and reliability to achieve the availability required for an ultra-high-power transmission asset.

We are developing a cable technology that is more efficient than standard copper cables at long-distance, high-capacity transmission. However, the real value of our technology is the economic and operational benefits it can deliver to the transmission system as a whole; it can enable reduction of equipment & infrastructure size and cost throughout the network. Whilst the equipment that our cable integrates with is standard in nature, for some applications, new designs and configurations are required to fully exploit the beneficial characteristics of our cable. We are working closely with leading academics and industry OEMs to study and develop such substation and converter station equipment and systems. As with any integrated DC transmission system, we do require power conversion and protection equipment to operate seamlessly with our cables. We undertake detailed integrated system studies to understand the operability, constraints and requirements for such systems such that they can inform our cable design and deliver optimised system-wide techno-economic benefit.